We were looking forward to the great food in Florence until we started studying Italian and could interpret some of the names of the typical foods. Since Bill hates cooked vegetables, we were already off to a bad start, but when we heard about the favorite food, tripe (the intestines of a cow) we were really freaked and decided to be careful about what we ordered. (We saw people eating tripe in the outdoor market as it was dredged out of a pot of meat juice and fat, and slapped on to a sandwich of boiled beef.) It looked like white sausage casing and extremely gross!
We are really just talking about dinners now, since the hotel provided the breakfast and lunch gratis.
Our first dinners were fixed price meals, where all of the courses are included in the price. Keeping in mind that the dollar was worth 60 cents, a typical dinner (as in the picture of an outdoor cafe) will run 10-15 euros ($14-21). It may have a pasta, some chicken, and a salad--pedestrian at best. A meal on the run might be pizza or a stuffed sandwich with a cup of warm coke for perhaps 8 euros ($11). The only way to get really good food--the food you have read about and drooled over is to go to a really good restaurant and plan to pay--a lot! We did that for our last night there. We had seen a restaurant in the Rick Steves book that looked really good, so off we set to find it. It was raining occasionally, and we seemed to walk for miles, when we came to the street in question. We shared the narrow street with some vagabonds (to put it nicely) and a few garbage cans, but then, in the distance, we saw some people waiting to get into a door, and sure enough, it was our restaurant. Normally, they wouldn't take you without reservations, but it was not a very busy night, so they kindly took us in.
The service was sooo slow, until we realized that the waiter did nothing until we directed him to do so. Finally we ordered the three courses. I had a tasty onion soup that was bold but not overpowering, a cheese and pear over greens salad that was outstanding, and veal with potatoes for the main course. Bill had a tortellini soup, shared my salad, and steak (from a breed of steer unique to Tuscany). It was a memorable meal, with each part being very tasty and wonderful. The eat and wait and discussion and wait, meant that the meal took 2 1/2 to 3 hours, which is typical. This is a Florentine evening activity, evidently, so you are not only buying a meal, but you are renting a seat! We added bottle of wine (should have had red, but we don't like red, so we had white) and a bottle of water, for a grand total of $180 ! And we were cheap! Needless to say, once was all that we could afford.
But the best food in Florence was the Gelato--the wonderful ice cream, custard, of a million flavors. We had it nearly every day, and normally that would be disastrous for the waist line, but we walked 10 hours a day, so we didn't gain weight. It is the best ice cream anywhere.
We ate in a McDonald's one night, and it was great to taste American food and coffee far from home.